Аdvertiser Disclosure
Home > Best Overall Home Warranty

Top 5 Best Home Warranty Companies (Which Are Scammy?)

Top Best Home Warranty Companies For Older Homes Review

Looking for the best home warranty company that’ll actually help you save you money on home repair without all the headache and scammy tactics?

Perfect, you’re in the right place!

Because after 100+ tests and 68 reviews, we at ReviewHomeWarranties.com put together an interactive home warranty finder tool to help you locate the best home warranty for your specific situation.

Below you’ll find our unique interactive home warranty finder tool to help you locate the best home warranty that fits your specific financial situation (preferred deductible, monthly cost range, etc) in your local area and State.

We update this tool with fresh data and rankings every day!

Editor's Choice
97.0

$50 Off Your Plan
Claim Offer
Best Overall
97.5

Limited Offer: $50 Off + 1 month free
Claim Offer
Most Affordable
95.8

Limited Time: $150 Off + 2 Free Months + roof coverage
Claim Offer

Compare the Best Home Warranty Plans By Company as of October, 21st, 2020

More Filters
Company
Plan
Premium (Year)
Deductible
Limit
Coverage
Get free quote
Company
Plan
Rating
Basic Plan
Level:
Silver
Type:
Combo
$475
$85
$500 - $1,500
57%
Details
Basic Plan
Rating: 97.50
Level:
Silver
Type:
Combo
Deductible
$85
Limit
$500 - $1,500
Premium(Year)
$475
Coverage
57%
Details
Combo Plan
Level:
Type:
Combo
$720
$75
$1,000 - $3,000
83%
Details
Combo Plan
Rating: 97.00
Level:
Type:
Combo
Deductible
$75
Limit
$1,000 - $3,000
Premium(Year)
$720
Coverage
83%
Details
Platinum Care plan
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
$696
$60
$500 - $2,000
68%
Details
Platinum Care plan
Rating: 95.80
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
Deductible
$60
Limit
$500 - $2,000
Premium(Year)
$696
Coverage
68%
Details
Complete Home Plan
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
$600
$150
$1,000 - $2,000
93%
Details
Complete Home Plan
Rating: 95.40
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
Deductible
$150
Limit
$1,000 - $2,000
Premium(Year)
$600
Coverage
93%
Details
Platinum Plan
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
$624
$75
$400 - $500
72%
Details
Platinum Plan
Rating: 95.20
Level:
Platinum
Type:
Combo
Deductible
$75
Limit
$400 - $500
Premium(Year)
$624
Coverage
72%
Details

As a reminder, the table above is updated every day with fresh data so you know you’re getting up-to-date information.

It’s also worth calling out our top picks may be updated at any time depending on changes companies make to their plans.

Below are our detailed reviews of each of the top home warranty companies on our list.

After the reviews, we also cover a number of frequently asked questions related to home warranties.

Make sure to read those in-detail to ensure you get the best deal and don’t buy the wrong coverage!

 

Choice Home Warranty Review (Best Overall Home Warranty)

  • Service Fee: $85
  • Coverage: 9/10
  • Limits: 9/10
  • Exclusions: 9/10
  • Affordability: 10/10
  • Customer Service: 9.5/10
  • Rating: 97.50

Visit Website

(848) 237-1571
choice home warranty

Why Do We Like Choice?

Out of all the home warranty companies we reviewed, Choice Home Warranty has the most comprehensive plans, good payout limits, minimal number exclusions, quality customer service, and affordable cost.

Choice has two main home warranty plans. The “Basic Plan” and the more comprehensive “Total Plan” covering 15 home appliances (dishwasher, etc) and systems (duct work, water heater, etc). They also have “Optional Coverage” for add on items most homeowners don’t usually have, which include pools and spas, well pump, sump pump, roof leaks, other extraneous items. 

Based on our review, Choice’s “Total” plan covers these items at a more affordable price point than its competitors although has a few more exclusions, which is how they can justify charging a lower monthly payment.

The thing about home warranties is that they are a bit complicated with a lot of moving parts that may confuse most homeowners on what’s covered versus what’s not covered.

A key deciding factor in our review looking for the best home warranty company is finding one with top quality customer service to help customers like you walk through the claims process so you don’t have to worry about nasty surprises when you need service.

That said, Choice has 24 hours a day 7 days a week 365 days a year availability and a 48 hour response time to get a contractor out to your home. Other providers tend to have slower response times and are less communicative about when technicians are assigned to your claim.

Policy On Pre-Existing Issues or Older Units?

Choice covers appliances regardless of age or existing wear and tear, so you don’t need to worry about signing up and not getting covered due to age assuming you’ve properly maintained the item over it’s life. 

What’s not covered is if you or someone else breaks the unit regardless of when it happens. All home warranties, regardless of company, won’t cover a unit you break through negligence or misuse (i.e., baby sticks chocolate bar into VCR).

Pros

  • Good Limits (up to $1,500)
  • Minimal Exclusions
  • More Affordable 

Cons

  • Only 15 Home Appliances & Systems Covered 

American Home Shield Review (Editor’s Choice)

  • Service Fee: $75 – $125
  • Coverage: 10/10
  • Limits: 10/10
  • Exclusions: 9.5/10
  • Affordability: 7/10
  • Customer Service: 9/10
  • Rating: 97.00

Visit Website

(866) 464-7521

american home shield home warranty

Why Do We Like American Home Shield?

Far and away the most thorough and transparent home warranty company we reviewed is American Home Shield. They are the gold standard. If you spend any amount of time on their website, it’s clear that they are very upfront about what they do cover and don’t cover when compared to their competitors.

In fact, they go out of their way to tell you they cover things their competitors don’t like rust or plumbing stoppages.

They also have the best home warranty coverage with an astounding 21 systems and major appliances including trash compactor, smoke detectors, and clothes washer. They also have the fewest number of exclusions with the highest dollar limit payout amounts ranging from $1,000 – $3,000 per claim.

Think of American Home Shield as the “BMW” or “Mercedes” of home warranty companies. More expensive than Choice, but with better coverage and limits.

Policy On Pre-Existing Issues or Older Units?

Very similar to Choice, American Home Shield covers old systems and appliances that break down due to wear and tear, but they do not cover pre-existing issues or negligence related to the misuse of your appliance or system!

Pros

  • Highest Payout Limits (up to $3,000)
  • Widest Coverage (21 systems and appliances)
  • Fewest Exclusions

Cons

  • Most Expensive

Select Home Warranty Review (Most Affordable)

  • Service Fee: $75
  • Coverage: 8/10
  • Limits: 8/10
  • Exclusions: 8/10
  • Affordability: 10/10
  • Customer Service: 8/10
  • Rating: 95.80

Visit Website

(888) 370-3954
select home warranty

Why Do We Like Select Home Warranty?

Select Home Warranty made our list as a best budget friendly home warranty option. They have lower limits ranging from $500 – $2,000 per claim but also lower service fee costs and potentially reduced annual premiums as low $325 per year if you opt into multiple year contracts, far below other competitors.

If you opt for their “Platinum Care” they are on-par with other providers in terms of what they actually cover.

Overall, a great budget option for people who want a home warranty but can’t afford Choice or American Home Shield.

Policy On Pre-Existing Issues or Older Units?

Very similar to Choice and American Home Shield, Select covers old systems and appliances that break down due to wear and tear, but they do not cover pre-existing issues or negligence related to the misuse of your appliance or system!

Pros

  • Most Affordable Service Contracts 
  • Roof leaks Are Covered In Their Platinum Plan

Cons

  • Ultra Pushy Sales
  • 3 Days To Submit Claim
  • Weaker Network Of Contractors

Total Home Protect Review (Best For Larger Systems)

  • Service Fee: $75
  • Coverage: 8/10
  • Limits: 7/10
  • Exclusions: 7.5/10
  • Affordability: 8/10
  • Customer Service: 8/10
  • Rating: 95.20

Visit Website

(267) 824-4010

total home protection home warranty

Why Do We Like Total Home Protect?

Total Home Warranty made our list as a home warranty with above average protection on more robust systems like septic systems and roof coverage.

Their monthly cost comes out to around ~$45 per month for their basic “Gold” plan, which puts them on the more expensive side of the scale when compared to other top home warranties on our list with better coverage.

Most home warranties do not cover anything related to your roof but Total Home Protect does, which we found to be unique to their offering helping them crack our top list.

Policy On Pre-Existing Issues or Older Units?

Very similar to Choice and AHS, Total Home Protect covers old systems and appliances that break down due to wear and tear, but they do not cover pre-existing issues or negligence related to the misuse of your appliance or system!

Pros

  • You Can Choose Your Own Technicians
  • Roof Coverage

Cons

  • More Exclusions Than Most Competitors
  • The Worst BBB score
  • Low Payout Limits ($500)

First American Home Warranty Review (Best Customer Service)

  • Service Fee: $75 – $100
  • Coverage: 8/10
  • Limits: 7/10
  • Exclusions: 7.5/10
  • Affordability: 8/10
  • Customer Service: 9.5/10
  • Rating: 94.90

Visit Website

(888) 445-5837

first american home warranty

Why Do We Like First American Home Warranty?

First American Home Warranty made our list as a home warranty with above average customer service mixed with in with a decent price point.

The only drawback was that they aren’t nationwide lacking coverage in the following states: ND, MN, WI, IL, NY, VT, NH, ME, MA, CT , RI , DE, AL, HI, LA,

Their plan options include a “Basic“ plan, which only covers appliances and will run you about $28 per month. Their combo plan, which covers major systems and appliances branded the “Premier” plan costs around to ~$43 per month.

Overall a good home warranty provider, but just lacking the coverage, which would have helped make a better case for “best overall home warranty company”.

Policy On Pre-Existing Issues or Older Units?

Again, all of the home warranty providers seem to have adopted a similar policy in that they cover “old” appliances and systems that break down due to wear and tear, but they do not cover pre-existing issues or negligence related to the misuse of your appliance or system!

Pros

  • Great Customer Service (B+ BBB Score)
  • Online Chat Support

Cons

  • Not Available In 15 States
  • Can’t Choose Your Own Contractor

Our Top Picks Recap

  # 1 Choice Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 97.50
  • $50 Off + 1 month free
  • Won't deny coverage if systems/appliances are old
  • Free cancellation within 30 days
  • Emergency service available
  • Reservice for failed repairs
  # 2 American Home Shield
Editorial Rating 97.00
  • Get $50 off
  • Lower chance of claim denial
  • 24/7 service calls and online service
  • Large and established firm
  • Choose your own service fee!
  • Market veteran
  # 3 Select Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 95.80
  • $150 off + 2 months free
  • FREE Roof Leak Coverage
  • Good selection of plans
  • High contractor professionalism
  • $0 transfer fee
  • First 30 days: Free cancellation
  # 4 Cinch Home Services
Editorial Rating 95.40
  • Get $100/ $50 off!
  • Large number of homeowners
  • Clients report fair compensation
  • Delays in repairs reported
  # 5 Total Home Protection
Editorial Rating 95.20
  • $150 OFF + 2 Months Free
  • Limited Roof Coverage
  • Comprehensive coverage plans
  • 1 day to submit claim
  • Limited availability (6 states)

How We Rated The “Best Home Warranty Company”

Now that we’ve gone through the top companies on our list, we wanted to put together our write up to help you understand how we’ve rated each of these companies.

Your trust is means a lot to us so it’s important that you know how our selection of top home warranty companies was made.

Our ratings are based on an analysis of 68 home warranty issuers as well as customer feedback.

This data helped drive which areas of home warranties we wanted to review and include in our write-ups. Specifically, we rated home warranty companies on the following areas:

  • Service Fee
  • Coverage
  • Exclusions
  • Limits
  • Affordability
  • Customer Service
  • BBB Rating & Profile

We graded each company based on these areas. See below for a description of each and how we considered them in our review!

The “Service Fee” And Our Rating

If you’re unfamiliar with how home warranties work, you sign up for service, pay the yearly fee (or “premium”) and then if you ever need service you have to pay the “service fee” when a contractor comes out to inspect your broken appliance or system.

This fee is also called a “trade service call fee”, and it’s kind of like a deductible, but you pay it every time regardless if the home warranty company fixes your unit or not.

You can think of service fees like “co-payments” when you go to the doctor. They prevent homeowners from constantly calling the home warranty company by charging a fee so when there is actually a problem you’re willing to spend a bit of money for someone to come out and look at it.

Some home warranty companies have a set fee like Choice Home Warranty, which charges a flat $85 per service call. Other companies like American Home Shield, let you pick from a range ($75 – $125). If you pick $75 then your yearly premium for coverage goes up, if you pick $125 it goes down.

This is actually a good thing to have, because if you think you’ll use your plan a lot, picking the lower fee will save you money. Either way, all home warranty companies will charge you this fee, so it’s important for us to call it out in our review.

Considering The Coverage In Our Rating

When picking your home warranty, you need to pay special attention to the coverages because this refers to what is actually covered in your plan. Some plans have systems and appliances bundled together, others do not. 

To make it even more confusing, some plans cover as many as 21 systems and appliances, others cover only 15 leaving out key systems you might use.

In our review we dig into the nitty gritty details of the service contracts to vet out what’s covered and what’s not within each plan so you can make an informed decision.

How Exclusions Affect Our Rating

Exclusions are a critical facet in a home warranty service contract, because it protects the home warranty company from things that may cause your home appliances or systems to break, which are unrelated to normal wear and tear. In our data we found that heating and air conditioning were among the most common requests in home warranty claims. Below you can see our full breakdown!

Types of Repairs Covered by Home Warranty

If there are a lot of exclusions in your contract, it makes it easier for your home warranty company to try and disqualify your repair request.

For example, a common cause of disqualification often used by home warranty companies is “improper installation”. This means whoever installed the appliance or system didn’t do it correctly, therefore the unit was more likely to break down sooner than it would have through normal use, thus it is excluded from coverage.

Another example exclusion might be that all the parts of your clothes dryer are covered except for the knobs and dials on the actual machine! If you were to break off the knob on your clothes dryer, your home warranty service provider is not on the hook to help you fix it.

Perhaps there is rust buildup and corrosion in your plumbing system. Most home warranty companies explicitly exclude rust from coverage, but American Home Shield does cover rust related repairs, which is great for you. Had you gone with a different provider like Total Home Protection, it would have been excluded! 

So each company handles exclusions a bit differently, which we have accounted for in our review.

Now on one hand exclusions stink, but on the other hand, they are in place to prevent bad actors from abusing the policy. If home warranty companies DIDN’T have exclusions, it’s unlikely there would be any in business.

At the end of the day, what you need to know is that if you think your refrigerator is nearing the end of its life, and the home warranty plan you’re considering has a long list of exclusions related to refrigerators, you should probably look elsewhere or consider upgrading your plan for more robust coverage.

Also, our recommendation is to get a home inspection to really understand the current state of your home. Then get that home inspector to walk you through their report with a sample contract from your home warranty company so you know exactly what’s excluded and what’s not excluded BEFORE you want to make a claim.

How Limits Affect Our Rating

Where the “limits” come into play are the caps on actual payouts you can receive for repairs on covered items. You want this number to be as high as possible so you can get higher payouts.

For example, Choice Home Warranty has a limit of $1,500 for heating systems, which means that it will payout up to $1,500 on covered claims to help repair the unit. If the actual cost is $3,000 to repair the unit quoted by the contractor, you would need to cover the difference between the coverage and the final bill.

Similar to exclusions, limits are meant to protect home warranty companies and your limit will usually depend on how much you’re willing to pay for your annual premium.

For example, American Home Shield has some of the highest limits availible (up to $3,000) but also charge close to the highest annual premium for coverage.

Part of our review was locating the best home warranty company with a good balance of monthly cost for their plans and dollar limit payout.

Affordability of The Plan Importance

When reviewing each company, we also looked at the general affordability of each plan. The costs of home warranties of annual premiums and deductibles can vary by state. Below, you can find data for all 50 states including Rhode Island, Texas, New York, California, Alaska, North Dakota, Montana and Hawaii.

Based on our data, we put together a graphic of what you can expect to be charged on average by state as well as the general availability of home warranty companies.

Distribution of Home Warranty Cost and Availability by State

There needs to be a balance between coverage and the cost of coverage, which is your premium paid. More expensive providers like American Home Shield have higher limits but also cost substantially more than value based providers like Choice Home Warranty. 

Companies like Total Home Protection have very similar fees related to Choice but substantially lower limits. For example, Choice has $1,500 limits where THP has $500 limits, but Choice is a bit cheaper. This means if your furnace breaks down over the winter, THP will give you a maximum of $500 for repairs while Choice $1,500.

Also, when negotiating a contractor with a home warranty provider, you’ll likely get offered multiple year deals in exchange for lower yearly premiums. So keep that in mind if you find a home warranty company you like. 

In our review, we call this out so you can make the right decision that fits your budget.

Read Also: Can I Have Warranty Coverage For My Washington, D.C. Home?

Quality Customer Service Rated

The last area we looked at in-detail was customer service.

Out of our data, we found that about 7% of the customers complained about tricky or vague terms and conditions, and more than 33% experienced problems with coverage of their home systems or appliances. See below for a breakdown each the complaints by type from our data.

Home Warranty Customer Complaints by Tyoe

Home warranties are notoriously difficult to navigate so it’s important that the company has a good customer service center to field your questions and set up service calls if something breaks.

For example, are the answers you get from the company consistent between customer service representatives? Do they quickly and promptly schedule contractors to come out on service calls? Do they offer to refund service fees if something goes wrong during the claim as a gesture of goodwill?

These are all things we’re looking for when reviewing each home warranty company below.


Our Top Picks Recap

  # 1 Choice Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 97.50
  • $50 Off + 1 month free
  • Won't deny coverage if systems/appliances are old
  • Free cancellation within 30 days
  • Emergency service available
  • Reservice for failed repairs
  # 2 American Home Shield
Editorial Rating 97.00
  • Get $50 off
  • Lower chance of claim denial
  • 24/7 service calls and online service
  • Large and established firm
  • Choose your own service fee!
  • Market veteran
  # 3 Select Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 95.80
  • $150 off + 2 months free
  • FREE Roof Leak Coverage
  • Good selection of plans
  • High contractor professionalism
  • $0 transfer fee
  • First 30 days: Free cancellation
  # 4 Cinch Home Services
Editorial Rating 95.40
  • Get $100/ $50 off!
  • Large number of homeowners
  • Clients report fair compensation
  • Delays in repairs reported
  # 5 Total Home Protection
Editorial Rating 95.20
  • $150 OFF + 2 Months Free
  • Limited Roof Coverage
  • Comprehensive coverage plans
  • 1 day to submit claim
  • Limited availability (6 states)

Why We Potentially Ignore The Better Business Bureau Score?

When it comes to doing your own research on whether to do business with a company, you likely go to the Better Business Bureau website to check their score right? Anything under a solid “A Rating” would be a signal that the company isn’t trustworthy right?

Normally this is a great idea, but when vetting home warranty companies, things get a bit more complicated.

You have to understand that due to the very nature of home warranties (i.e., complicated contracts, exclusions, etc) there will be an increase of negative customer experiences due to the misunderstanding of contract terms.

It’s a fact that home warranties can be valuable and can save you a lot of money if you use them correctly, but problems arise when homeowners think their home warranty is some kind of blanket coverage for all the stuff in your house. 

Many people who buy home warranties are misled by sales people or simply don’t read the contract they sign. The contracts by definition have to outline every exclusion a homeowner may come across. 

For example, say a homeowner buys a “Basic” plan from Choice Home Warranty because their refrigerator is getting old. Months later their fridge stops working, so they go to make a claim for repairs, except when they talk to the representative, they are told they needed to buy the “Total Plan” not the basic plan, which has more comprehensive coverage. This is a common scenario of misunderstanding that may result in a BBB complaint.

When reviewing companies, we need to take their BBB score with a grain of salt because of the complicated nature of home warranties and the fact that people only tend to complain when they have a problem.

That said, we look at the BBB score of each company to get a sense of reputation and see how the company reacts to resolving each customer issue. It’s one thing to get a negative customer complaint and try to remediate the situation through proper conflict resolution, it’s another thing to just ignore the customer.

— Frequently Asked Questions —

How Does A Home Warranty Work?

A home warranty works by covering systems and appliances inside your home.

This is different fr