American Residential Warranty Review

Why should you read this American Residential Warranty review? Because it will help you decide on whether or not to choose this company for your home warranty. While creating this review, our team at ReviewHomeWarranties analyzed important aspects of the company such as its trustworthiness, coverage plans, terms and conditions, reputation, and client reviews from the top-rated customer reporting sites and compared this information against other companies in this industry.

So, whatever state you live in, if you are looking for a home warranty provider, read this American Residential Warranty review carefully to make the right choice.

Updated for Apr 28, 2019

Official website:  

American Residential Warranty Reviews by Our Readers
Cast vote by clicking on either button above
Covered States
Hawaii Alaska Florida New Hampshire Michigan Vermont Maine Rhode Island New York Pennsylvania New Jersey Delaware Maryland Virginia West Virginia Ohio Indiana Illinois Connecticut Wisconsin North Carolina District of Columbia Massachusetts Tennessee Arkansas Missouri Georgia South Carolina Kentucky Alabama Louisiana Mississippi Iowa Minnesota Oklahoma Texas New Mexico Kansas Nebraska South Dakota North Dakota Wyoming Montana Colorado Idaho Utah Arizona Nevada Oregon Washington California
Ratings
Trustworthiness:
Plans and Coverage:
Feedback:
The Fine Print:
Promotions:
Editor Rating:
Reader Rating:
Covered Appliances and Systems
Icon
Facts and Figures
30 days
Effective in
24/7
Hours
$49
Cancellation
$360 - $1380
Premium
$75
Deductible
?
Limits
Pros And Cons
Excellent BBB rating A+
Market veteran
Low optional coverage costs
Different plan types available

Incomprehensive coverage
1 day to submit a claim
Online chat not supported
Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

Our Top-Rated Alternatives to American Residential Warranty

  # 1 Select Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 98.5
  • 24/7 service calls
  • Great annual promotions
  • Plans under $30/month
  • High contractor professionalism
  • Quick replacement payments
  • First 30 days: Free cancellation
  # 2 Choice Home Warranty
Editorial Rating 96.8
  • Market veteran
  • Large and established firm
  • Emergency service available
  • Free cancellation within 30 days
  • 24/7 service calls
  • Reservice for failed repairs
  # 3 Total Home Protection
Editorial Rating 91.2
  • Emergency service available
  • Free cancellation within 30 days
  • 24/7 service calls
  • Multiple optional coverage items
  • Clients praised communication
  • Reservice for failed repairs

Editorial Notes

American Residential Warranty provides nationwide service, covering the whole territory of the USA, which means that you can get their home warranty service wherever you live.

The company provides coverage which can meet demands to protect either systems, kitchen appliances, cooling and heating systems, or all of them. Furthermore, there is the ability to customize your plan by adding items you want to be covered without paying for items you do not need to be covered.

The advantages of the company also include the long cancellation period with refund and a lower cancellation fee than the industry average.

With a wide variety of plans and additional options for customized coverage, generous coverage limits, an A+ BBB rating, as well as a high rating from the customer reporting sites, American Residential Warranty can be considered a good choice—and a good value for your money as well.

Premium cost level:
Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

Trustworthiness

Can you consider American Residential Warranty a trustworthy company? The company’s experience and the covered territory may help you decide that.

Headquartered in Boca Raton, Florida, American Residential Warranty was launched in 2009. Services of ARW are backed and administered by TWG Home Warranty Services, Inc., who have over fifty years of industry experience. American Residential Warranty has spread their services across the USA, providing warranties to a vast number of homeowners. Such comprehensive coverage can be compared to Home Warranty of America’s; however, not every company can boast such wide coverage. Any disputes will be resolved in arbitration.

Accessibility

How to contact
Main Page >> Contact Us
Online chat
No
Social media

American Residential Warranty’s 24/7 call center ensures that clients get fast and high-quality service whenever they need it. Although the company doesn’t have an online chat, it has social media pages on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Google+.

Benchmarks American Residential Warranty Other companies

Company size
No data
0 1,650
Annual revenue
No data
0 $1,276,000,000
Number of homeowners
No data
0 2,200,000
Number of BBB complaints closed within last 3 years
46
0 14,850
Traffic
3,500
0 383,900
Number of independent contractors
No data
0 44,000

Reputation

BBB accreditation
A+ (Not Accredited)
Awards
2017 Best and Brightest Award, 2018 Best and Brightest Award, 2017 Top Workplaces by SunSentinel Media Group

Over the years, American Residential Warranty has gained a solid reputation as a reliable provider of home warranty coverage for their clients. Although the company isn’t accredited by the BBB, it has the highest rating of A+ that makes it comparable to Pride Home Warranty. Moreover, it is an award-winning home warranty company, as American Residential Warranty received the Best and Brightest Award in 2017. Thus, this company can be considered trustworthy.

Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

Coverage

To choose the best home warranty company and plan for your needs, you should know what is covered under the home warranty plans and what is not. To help you make the right choice, we researched the company’s coverage plans, pricing policy, as well as additional coverage, and compared these with the proposals of the company's competitors.

Unlike many other home warranty companies, American Residential Warranty offers five coverage plans to its customers: Kitchen Plus, Heating & Cooling, Platinum, Platinum Premier, and the 4-in-1 Bundle = Platinum Premier + Deluxe Advantage + Water and Sewer Lines + Ultimate Electronics Protection. The plans are priced at $457, $525, $589, $679, and $1,319 per year respectively. The company’s plans can be a good option for customers with different needs, as they can cover only kitchen appliances, heating and air conditioning systems, or both.

The Kitchen Plus Plan covers major kitchen appliances, such as kitchen exhaust fan, dishwasher, microwave, oven, disposal, and refrigerator. This type of plan best suits homeowners who only need coverage for their kitchen.

The Heating & Cooling Plan, as the name implies, provides coverage for the central home air conditioning system, heating system, whole house humidifier, water heater, along with the electrical system.

The Platinum Plan covers the same systems and appliances that both the Kitchen Plus Plan and the Heating & Cooling Plan do. So, this plan fits homeowners who want to feel secure in the proper operation of both the kitchen appliances and the heating and a/c systems in their home.

The Platinum Premier Plan provides coverage for the same items that the Platinum Plan does, plus ceiling fan, ductwork, plumbing stoppages, free-standing ice maker, and garage door opener.

And the last one, the 4-in-1 Bundle = Platinum Premier + Deluxe Advantage + Water and Sewer Lines + Ultimate Electronics Protection, covers PC and TV, in addition to the Platinum Premier Plan’s coverage. So, if the TV and PC are also important for you to be covered, you won’t go wrong by choosing this plan.

If any of these plans don’t cover some systems or appliances you need coverage for, you can add them separately for an extra charge. It includes air conditioner, ceiling fan, free-standing ice maker, heating system, plumbing, oven, refrigerator, and water heater.

Customers can choose month-to-month, quarterly, or annual payment plans. The deductible is $75, which is the average industry price. As for the coverage limits, American Residential Warranty offers $500 to $2,500, which is even higher than the limits offered by some industry giants such as Select Home Warranty with limits up to $2,000, or Choice Home Warranty at $1,500.

American Residential Warranty also provides an option to increase the coverage by selecting items from a predefined list of add-ons, the cost of which is $72 to almost $170. The additional coverage list consists of maintenance of well pump, pool or spa, pump, washer and dryer, external sewer line system, refrigerator ice maker, and an external water line system. The limits for add-ons are also high at $500 to $2,500.

Summary of plans and coverage:

Coverage Term
Service Call Fee
ItemsLimit Platinum Combo Plan Gold Combo Plan Silver Combo Plan Silver Systems Plan Platinum Combo Plan Platinum Combo Plan Optional Coverage
Premium Amount - $54.99 $174.96 $679.87 $46.99 $151.96 $589.87 $29.99 $116.96 $457.87 $35.99 $134.96 $525.87 $114.99 $334.99 $1319.99 $94.99 $276.99 $1071.99 $71.88 - $167.88
Service Call Fee - $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 $75.00 -
Term, Month - 1 3 12 1 3 12 1 3 12 1 3 12 1 3 12 1 3 12 12
Coverage$500.00 - $1,000.00

It will be useful for you to also know not only what systems and appliances are covered by a home warranty company, but also what malfunctioning parts and components it covers.

Air Conditioning and Heating Systems

American Residential Warranty covers all parts and components essential for the a/c and heating systems functionality, including condensers, thermostats, relays, transformers, motors, compressors, and other elements. Be advised that improperly sized heating and cooling systems as well as free-standing or portable heat units will not be serviced.

There is also coverage available for accessible ductwork from the covered system unit to the point of attachment to registers or grills, and also all internal electrical parts and fan motors of the whole house humidifier.

Electrical System

American Residential Warranty covers malfunctions connected with all interior AC wiring, switches, fuses, single and two pole breakers. However, the company is not responsible for inadequate wiring capacity, power failure, shortage or power surge, as well as any damage or failure caused by circuit overload. Likewise, the warranty applies to ceiling fan motors and controls.

Plumbing System

American Residential Warranty offers repairs for all interior plumbing including angle stops, risers, waste vents, p-trap assemblies, and interior hose bibs provided all piping and plumbing are inside of the foundation perimeter. If there is a necessity to clear mainline, sewer, and lateral drain line stoppages, the company will help you with this problem if it’s up to 100 feet from the access point. Note that the company won’t take responsibility for conditions of excessive or insufficient water pressure, as well as any repairs necessary to access interior lines or pipes.

Home Appliances

American Residential Warranty provides coverage for all components important for the proper functioning of the main home appliances, such as motors, control boards, switches, relays, condensers, compressors, and other parts. Any cosmetic damages, which do not affect the operation of the equipment, such as scratches, dents, or chipping, are not protected by this company.

In addition to the items and systems listed above, American Residential Warranty’s plans can be extended with coverage for both pool and spa, well pump, pump, washer and dryer, external sewer line system, refrigerator ice maker, and an external water line system.

Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

The Fine Print

Item
Comparison to Industry
Coverage effective after
Above industry average
Cancellation with refund within
Above industry average
Cancellation fee
Above industry average
Automatic policy renewal
As 94.6% of industry
Time to cancel automatic renewal
n/a
Fee for contract transfer
Above industry average
Max time to submit claim
At industry minimum
Repair timeframe
At industry maximum
Repair timeframe (weekends and holidays)
n/a
Free second opinion
n/a
Emergency service available
As 86.8% of industry
Hours for service calls
As 85.2% of industry
Reservice if repairs fail
Standard for industry
Free reservice period (parts)
Below industry average
Free reservice period (labor)
At industry minimum

American Residential Warranty has accessible information about their terms and conditions. Our team did the best to provide you with the company’s regulations and to compare them to the industry standards.

The company’s services will be available 30 days after making a commitment, which is a longer period than most home warranty companies provide. Clients can cancel the contract with a refund within 30 days, which is the maximum period in the industry.

If you have a breakdown, you must inform the company representatives within just one day, which is less than the industry practice. Like most companies in the market, American Residential Warranty offerers an automatic policy renewal. However, according to the company’s conditions, you can cancel the renewal by paying a $49 fee, which is just a little less than the industry average. In case of an emergency situation, immediate service will be provided.

Unfortunately, if any repair made by the company’s contractor fails, the free reservice period for parts is only 60 days with 30 days for labor, which is less than most home warranty companies offer.

Since there is no data about the repair timeframes, you may face some inconvenience as unexpected repair delays may occur. There is also no data about the availability of a free second opinion in situations where you disagree with the contractor’s report.

Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

Customer Reviews and Feedback

Quotes from actual customer reviews:

I recently had my very old dishwasher stop working. ARW got someone out right away which I appreciated. They came and determined that it was actually an electrical problem. I called to update ARW as to what the appliance technician said regarding an electrical problem. Right away they assisted me and set up an electrician which was professional and walked through my problem with me and fixed it. I've already complimented that service but wanted to take the time to thank ARW for their attentiveness and concern for my problem. They moved the service fee over to the second call with I greatly appreciated. They were polite, professional and treated me like I was family. They demonstrated that they strive to not only provide and connect customers with professionals but believe that you should get the service you expect and pay for. Keep up the good work!! Thanks ARW.Really!!

Yelp, Chicago, Illinois February 28, 2019

I'm going to update my prior reviews to 3 stars. Although I've had my issues with ARW's service, I have to say that they showed some level of customer service with my recent issue. I was contacted again by Chris of ARW and he was very honest about previous challenges and lapses in communication. He then said he would look into my issues again and get back to me. Chris contacted me again via email the same day and resolved the issue to my satisfaction. My previous impression was that ARW was a company that was taking money without caring about the customer service experience. The fact that they followed up again, were forthright and honest about their shortcomings goes a long way towards restoring my confidence in them. I'm not looking for freebies but I do want a company that makes an effort to meet the expectations of their customers.

Yelp, Rockville, Maryland January 8, 2018

Summary of ratings from popular review sites:

American Residential Warranty Industry Average

Website

Relative Score

Adjusted Score

Yelp
48
156
2.0
1.7
2.8
Ripoff Report
18
26
1.0
1.0
2.4
Pissed Consumer
10
146
3.0
1.4
5.0
BBB
284
223
4.5
3.1
3.9
Google Reviews
368
472
4.4
3.2
3.5
YSCAM
6
11
1.0
1.0
2.4

Summary Rating
2.9
2.1
2.9

Types of repairs performed according to customer feedback:

Washer Plumbing Disposal Electrical Dryer Air conditioner Dishwasher Microwave Refrigerator Oven Heating system Water heater Garage door Ductwork

Main takeaway points from customer feedback:

American Residential Warranty
Industry Average
Good work
27%
12%
Professional contractor
14%
6%
Good communication
5%
5%
Money offer
0%
3%
Fast work
10%
3%
Act of good faith
0%
0%
Communication problems
17%
18%
Repair delay
10%
17%
Claim denial
6%
12%
Tricky terms
6%
7%
Unexpected costs
2%
7%
Unprofessional contractor
2%
7%
Payment delay
2%
2%

Before making a decision on whether or not sign a contract with American Residential Warranty, it is wise to learn about other people’s experiences with the company to avoid being disappointed or unexpectedly surprised. For this reason, we studied the most recent and relevant reviews from around 1,000 customers on six consumer reporting sites including Yelp, Ripoff Report, Pissed Consumer, BBB, Google  Reviews, and YSCAM. We found that the overall level of client satisfaction with the company is one point higher than the industry average, according to the ratings given to American Residential Warranty on these sites. For example, their rating on Google  Reviews is 4.4 compared to the industry average of 3.2. This makes American Residential Warranty quite competitive in the market.

The most common types of repairs performed according to customer feedback are problems with washer, microwave, air conditioner, and dishwasher.

More than twice as many customers than the industry average were satisfied with the work of the company and the professionalism of the contractors. A total of 14% of the company clients praised contractor professionalism vs.6% on average. Fast work was mentioned almost three times as often for American Residential Warranty as fro other home warranty companies.

Only 6% of customers had situations where their claims were rejected vs. 12% on average, perhaps because they did not fully or correctly understand the company’s terms and conditions. Repair delays were mentioned by 10% of the customers vs. 17% on average. Tricky terms were mentioned by 6% of the customers.

All of the above data allows us to consider this home warranty company reliable, but with tricky terms in some cases.

Not available through RHW Click Here to View Alternatives

The Final Words

Is American Residential Warranty good?

Our team of analysts did a comprehensive study of American Residential Warranty’s services, comparing it in terms of coverage plans, prices, limits, terms and conditions, and customer feedback against its competitors.

American Residential Warranty is an experienced company with a solid reputation, providing home warranties to customers all over the USA. The company has been around for almost ten years.

This home warranty provider offers many coverage plans, including an additional list of protected items. This wide selection can be suitable for any needs, along with affordable premiums and average service call fees. The company’s terms and conditions show that American Residential Warranty aims to satisfy its clients.

As to the customer feedback, we see that the company rating is higher than the industry average. In addition, the company has the highest rating from the BBB, which confirms its reputation.

Overall, we can assume that American Residential Warranty is trustworthy and a really good value for your money. If you agree with this, get a quote from the company. If not, go through the list of home warranty companies on ReviewHomeWarranties.com, and choose the one that fits your needs best. 

View Alternative Companies
Ratings
Trustworthiness:
Plans and Coverage:
Feedback:
The Fine Print:
Promotions:
Editor Rating:
Reader Rating:
Not available through RHW