We have reviewed 10 of the most prominent home warranty service providers in the USA. Our criteria was reputation and client reviews, pricing, clarity of T&C’s. View a complete list of all home warranty service providers review below:

Choice Home Warranty Review
98.5
Rating
🏆 More Than 10 Years on the Market

🏆  Most Comprehensive Plans

🏆 Customer Satisfaction Award

 

__________________________________________

✘ Coverage Capped at $500

 

 
Read Full Choice Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, District of Columbia + 35 More States
Select Home Warranty Review
94.4
Rating
🏆 Most Comprehensive Coverage

🏆 Customer Satisfaction Award

🏆 Nationwide Service

 




✘ Less than 10 years on the market

 

 
Read Full Select Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 38 More States
Total Home Protection Review
91.2
Rating
🏆 Customer Service Available 24/7

🏆 BBB rating A-

🏆 Comprehensive Coverage Plans

🏆 Pre-Screened Contractors




✘ Limited customer reviews

✘ Less than 5 years on the market
Read Full Total Home Protection Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 23 More States
America’s 1st Choice Home Club Review
87.9
Rating
🏆  80%+ Positive Reviews Online

🏆 Modular Plans

🏆 BBB Rating B




✘ Coverage limited at $500 per system per contract term
Read Full America’s 1st Choice Home Club Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 35 More States
Landmark Home Warranty Review
86.4
Rating
🏆 Customer Satisfaction Award

🏆 Most Comprehensive and Affordable Plans

🏆 Biggest Add-Ons Selection

🏆 Customizable Service Fee

🏆 Over 70 000 Households Covered Each Year




✘ Available in 6 states only

 
Read Full Landmark Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

Arizona, Texas, Utah + 3 More States
American Home Guard Review
83.8
Rating
🏆 Most Comprehensive Coverage

🏆 High Customer Satisfaction

🏆 30 Day Money Back Guarantee

🏆 24/7 Customer Service




✘ Less than 10 years on the market

✘ Not accredited with Better Business Bureau

 
Read Full American Home Guard Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 36 More States
Advanced Home Warranty Review
83.4
Rating
🏆 Customer Service Available 24/7

🏆 Comprehensive Coverage Plans

🏆 First Month Free

 




✘ Customer Reviews Not Available

✘ BBB Rating Not Available
Read Full Advanced Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, District of Columbia + 38 More States
First American Home Buyers Protection Review
76.2
Rating
🏆 Industry Veteran Award

🏆 Comprehensive Coverage Award

🏆 Top 3 Cheapest Plans ($25/month)

 




✘ Coverage is capped at $500

✘ Many Negative Reviews

✘Limited Selection of Optional Coverage Items

 

 
Read Full First American Home Buyers Protection Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 36 More States
Old Republic Home Protection Review
74.2
Rating
🏆 Industry Veteran Award

🏆 Most Comprehensive Plans

🏆 A+ rating on BBB




✘ Not Available in All States

✘Pricing Varies by State

 
Read Full Old Republic Home Protection Review Here

Clients from:  

Arizona, California, Florida, Georgia, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia + 14 More States
Home Security of America Review
72.3
Rating
🏆 More than 30 Years on the Market

🏆 Customer Satisfaction Award

🏆 Online Invoice Submission




✘ Coverage Capped at $500

✘ Service not available in all states

✘ Limited Coverage for Home Sellers

 
Read Full Home Security of America Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 33 More States
TotalProtect Home Warranty Review
70.2
Rating
🏆  Industry Veteran Award

🏆 Top 3 Cheapest Plans ($18.95)

🏆 Comprehensive Coverage




✘ Claims Capped at $1,500

✘ Limited Optional Coverage

✘Coverage Varies by State

 

 
Read Full TotalProtect Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 38 More States
Secure Home Warranty Review
68.8
Rating
🏆 Nationwide Service Availability

🏆 Best Optional Coverge




✘ Less than 5 years on the market

✘ C- rating on BBB

 
Read Full Secure Home Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 38 More States
American Home Shield Review
68.4
Rating
🏆 Industry Veteran Award

🏆 Most Comprehensive Coverage

🏆 Top 3 Cheapest Plans ($18.99)




✘ Coverage Capped at $1,500

✘ Claims Get Denied

✘ Aggressive Marketing Strategies

 
Read Full American Home Shield Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 38 More States
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty Review
67.8
Rating
🏆 Customer Satisfaction Award

🏆 Most Comprehensive Plans

🏆 Industry Veteran Award




✘ Service availability is limited to 6 states

✘ Claims Get Denied

 

 
Read Full 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty Review Here

Clients from:  

 Illinois, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Maryland, Ohio, Texas, Utah, Virginia, District of Columbia + 38 More States

 Our parameters in composing home warranty service provider scores

We take score assigning very seriously. We look after what we believe most clients are after. Our goal is to make the search of a service provider easy and choose the companies which are most apt for our reader's requirements. Here are some of the things we take into consideration. You can view the exact criteria in each review, but here's the top level executive summary:


  1. We like credible service providers. Credible companies are ones that have clear contact address in the U.S, we know the names of the key guys like the CEO, and of course we have client reviews we have been able to locate from across the web.

  2. We like affordable prices. In each review you can find the complete array of plans available at this service provider, and the cost of each package or component.

  3. We like a  superb service. That's why we aggregate every client review we could locate online about each company, and make sure clients like the service they are getting.


 

We do not like

  1. Home warranty service providers who are not honest and transparent about the nature of their service, and who's behind the company. You can read some examples of such companies on our home warranty scams page.

  2. Home warranty service providers who do not provide exemplary service to clients. If clients are dissatisfied about the quality and nature of services they have been provided with, then we are not happy with this company as well.

  3. Home warranty providers who charge you through the roof for their services. Insurance companies of all kinds must make profit, we get that, but there is absolutely no point in purchasing a home warranty if you are going to pay massive amounts of cash each month on it. If you eventually pay more each month than it would cost you to use a professional, you are doing it all wrong.